The ETSU Africana Studies program statement is a well articulated explanation of and justification for the actions of the ETSU men’s basketball team’s kneeling actions. However it disregards a couple of critical facts/considerations. First, regardless of stated ‘intent,’ this kneeling action IS DISRESPECTFUL of the U.S. Flag, and by extension, to all who have served (and died) defending it. No matter how ‘just’ the cause, kneeling during the National Anthem is an intentional act of DISRESPECT when the correct, called for action is to stand and render respect. It is an overt act intended to call attention to one’s self and perhaps, by extension, one’s ’cause.’ So let’s look at that, and ask “Is there any alternative action that might raise equal (or greater) positive attention to your cause, while also demonstrating a sincere, clear personal commitment to that cause?” I would suggest the answer is yes. How about if you chose to kneel either during your introductions, or even better, kneel during each and every time-out! That would certainly generate a ton of discussion and clearly demonstrate personal, continuing commitment to the cause. It comes down to a matter of seeking support for your cause or making your cause intentionally alienate a huge portion of the very people you are seeking to influence. So what is your real intent?
Second, by what authority are you justified to implicitly represent the entire university by taking your actions in uniform and during a sanctioned university event? You have a clear right to demonstrate or protest as and individual (or group); however, that right does not include (mis)representing the university (or by extension its alumni) in your protest actions. In other words, if you feel strongly to demonstrate, then prove it by choosing a time and place where you (individually or collectively) can make your case without assuming the right/authority to represent the entire institution. Again, is your intent to call attention to yourself or to seek positive support for your cause? Is kneeling during the National Anthem going to engender real support or is it going to further alienate the very people who’s support/consideration you are seeking? Think about it; then act accordingly.
Submitted by LTC(Ret) Richard Measner, ETSU ROTC PMS (1988-1992)
