Editor’s note: This article discusses an alleged sexual assault. The East Tennessean generally does not identify people who report sexual assault. However, Sarah Cate Coons contacted the publication to share her experience and consented to being identified.

An East Tennessee State University freshman who reported being sexually assaulted in her residence hall on Oct. 16 says she is dissatisfied with how the ETSU Police Department and university officials have handled her case.

Sarah Cate Coons said she was in the hallway of her residence hall when a male student allegedly grabbed her inappropriately.

“A group of males was going around and knocking on doors,” Coons said.

According to the police report, ETSU police officers were already at the residence hall responding to an unrelated call when Coons reported the alleged assault.

The responding officer documented signs that the accused individual had been drinking.

“Upon making contact, I detected the odor of alcohol coming from [the accused], who admitted to having consumed alcoholic beverages,” the report stated.

The individual was taken for further questioning.

“During questioning, [the offender] did admit to being in the hallway but denied touching Ms. Coons when he walked by her,” the report stated.

According to the report, the individual was instructed not to enter the residence hall for “the remainder of the semester or until otherwise advised.”

The individual was referred to university authorities in connection with allegations of sexual battery under Tennessee Code Annotated 39-13-505 and underage alcohol consumption under Tennessee Code Annotated 57-3-412.

Concerns with ETSU police and Title IX

Coons said she has experienced a lack of professionalism, communication and support while navigating the reporting and investigation process.

She said she did not initially receive her case number and contacted the Johnson City Police Department in an attempt to obtain information about her case.

According to Coons, the initial report she received from ETSU police contained unredacted personal information, including Social Security and driver’s license numbers.

She said she returned the report to ETSU police and later received a redacted version.

Dissatisfied with the response from university police, Coons contacted the Johnson City Police Department to file a complaint and request that the department take over the investigation.

However, she said she was directed back to ETSU police and advised to request assistance from a specific officer.

When she returned to ETSU police, Coons said she met with two officers but felt uncomfortable with how the conversation was handled.

“I felt like I was in trouble for asking for help,” Coons said.

She described the interaction as feeling more like an interrogation than an opportunity to receive assistance.

Coons said she has also struggled with questions from university officials about what outcome she hopes to achieve through the process.

“What is your outcome [end goal]?” Coons said she has been asked repeatedly.

She said answering that question has been difficult because of the emotions surrounding the alleged incident.

Coons also expressed concerns about her experience with ETSU’s Title IX office, citing what she described as a lack of transparency, professionalism and timely communication.

“The coordinators have repeatedly tried to persuade me to pursue mediation instead of proceeding with the Title IX process, despite my clear objections,” Coons said.

She said she has experienced delayed email responses and difficulties obtaining information about the status of her case.

Coons has also shared her experience on Instagram through several accounts, including @thesafacollective, @etsujanedoes, @educatorfinley and her personal account.

University response

In a statement to The East Tennessean, ETSU confirmed that the matter remains under investigation through the university’s Title IX process.

“This matter is currently under investigation through East Tennessee State University’s Title IX process. To protect the integrity of the investigation and the privacy of those involved, the university cannot comment on specific allegations or individuals. ETSU takes all forms of sex-based harassment seriously and is committed to a fair and thorough process,” the university said.

Johnson City police response

The Johnson City Police Department also provided a statement explaining why it referred Coons back to ETSU police.

“The incident reportedly occurred on the campus of ETSU and therefore would fall under the jurisdiction of ETSU Public Safety. The individual was referred back to that agency. The Johnson City Police Department cannot take over a case that is already under investigation by another agency and falls outside its jurisdiction,” the department said.

Understanding Title IX

Title IX is a federal civil rights law established under the Education Amendments of 1972. It prohibits sex-based discrimination in educational programs and activities that receive federal financial assistance.

The law reads:

“No person in the United States shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any educational program or activity receiving federal financial assistance.”

Students seeking to report potential Title IX violations or obtain additional information about Title IX may contact ETSU’s Title IX office at titleix@etsu.edu or 423-439-8545.

Additional information and reporting forms are available at www.etsu.edu/titleix.

Author